Question:
Why don't people measure things in logical ways?
anonymous
2010-04-28 09:06:44 UTC
I live in Hawaii though I'm going to college on the mainland, so it constantly bugs me that when people talk about timezone, they use arcane acronyms like EST and whatnot. I quickly learned Hawaii's GMT offset and started to use it, and not only did people not know how their timezones compared to mine, they also didn't know what time it was in Hawaii from me telling them that I was on GMT-10.

Why do Americans stick to inches and feet? Scientists know how stupid that is and so should you.

And how about that 12 hour clock, huh?
Four answers:
Dbuga
2010-04-28 09:13:10 UTC
Societies are different. The metric system is not built into the US school system (although, I believe it should because it would probably be one of the most practical things you learn in middle school). Same thing with the 12-hour clock, tradition. And, to be honest, having been brought up with the 12-hour clock and not the metric system, it is not a priority to learn these things.
fizixx
2010-04-28 17:26:24 UTC
Probably because the 'logic' often times is dependent upon the technology at the time of their origination. Horses use to be measured in hands....literally. Why? Obviously, because it was, on average, accurate enough and the measurements weren't dependent on accuracy, and even if it were they didn't have the fine scales to measure them with anyway. We don't use that measure anymore......there are far more reliable and repeatable ways to do that.



Back when the English units were devised, apparently it was thought it to be the most 'logical' at the time....base ten number system since we have ten fingers and ten toes.



As technology advanced the English system has gotten clunky and cumbersome. As a scientist I wish they'd go to all metric in the USA too, but people here just don't want to do anything related to 'brain' work. So there is great resistance. I think the metric units should show up along side the English units for a period of 3 - 5 years and then drop the English units altogether.



As for time.....you will always gave to make adjustments for various location on the globe, so you use gmt - 4, or gmt + 5....whatever, you still have to remember if it's forward, or backward, and by how much. That convention really isn't any better than any other. See, I regard that like most of those hoaky memory courses where...in order to remember your new insurance salesman's name you have to remember 10 (whatever) other things instead. He wore a gray suit, so you picture an elephant at your door.....he had a beard so you have to imagine a pirate say......he was tall, so you think of a basketball player....and on and on. It's a common memory scheme that people think is great, but I happen to think it's idiotic. If you can remember those 10 things, then why can't you just remember the two....his name and number......yanno?



As far as the clock....that's so inconsequential that it's really pointless to mention. It's just a clock, most of it is by context. The 5 seconds you save designating 17 hundred hours without explanation of am/pm isn't really going to make you or break you....is it? Logic is fine and good if it's really worth while for daily life type stuff.
Tyler M
2010-04-28 16:11:43 UTC
WELL for special people like me I don't banter on about time zones or for that matter give a damn about who's what time from where I'm at, ALSO I'm in AZ one of a couple places that don't do the whole daylight savings time.... so sometimes were the same time as nevada and Cali and sometimes were different. All I care about is when I visit anyone I know I'm gonna be losing time going east and making time going west
aqh
2010-04-28 16:10:09 UTC
huh


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...